This month, the NRDC issued a report claiming one in four Americans are drinking water that comes from untested or contaminated systems. The report also identifies 12 states which NRDC claims had the most offenses. Overall, the report confirms what we already know. That we have a long way to go before fixing our nation’s aging infrastructure woes.
We at E&W would caution, however, against reaching the conclusion that the 12 states identified are the worst offenders. We believe such conclusion would be wrong and misleading. In fact, we would argue to the contrary, that many of the states listed, like New Jersey, Pennsylvania and Maryland, have robust drinking water programs where self-reporting and water quality is taken seriously and enforced. The data is also likely to reflect a State with many more small systems than others, such as Wisconsin that has over 10,000 small water systems. That’s a much bigger problem involving a highly fragmented water sector. As the NRDC reports notes, most of the offenses are related to small and rural systems.
Keep in mind that NRDC relied upon EPA’s enforcement database that lists violations or offenses that actually get reported. It is axiomatic that non-reported violations – by their very nature – will not be captured in a State or EPA databases. We should all be in agreement that more reporting is better than less reporting.
Toward this end, there are numerous states where reporting is not taken as seriously as those listed. Therefore, the results are almost invariably skewed, accurately depicting the compliance status of those states listed and less accurately depicting the status of those states omitted from the list.
States should not be “called-out” and unfairly criticized for taking self-reporting seriously. For those States you would expect more reported offenses – that we know. What we don’t know is what we all should be concerned about.
Here is the executive summary of the NRDC report.
REPORT: Nearly One in Four Americans’ Drinking Water Comes from Untested or Contaminated Systems
WASHINGTON – 77 million people—roughly a quarter of the U.S. population—spread across all 50 states were served by water systems reporting violations of the Safe Drinking Water Act in 2015, according to a report issued today by the Natural Resources Defense Council (NRDC). The offenses ranged from arsenic to nitrate contamination, and included often-serious failures to test or report contamination levels. A new threat to the nation’s water supplies comes in the form of dramatic cuts to the Environmental Protection Agency’s 2018 budget—including programs designed to safeguard our nation’s drinking water—despite President Trump’s recognition that “crystal clear water” is vitally important to the country.
“America is facing a nationwide drinking water crisis that goes well beyond lead contamination,” said Erik Olson, Health Program Director at NRDC and a report co-author. “The problem is two-fold: there’s no cop on the beat enforcing our drinking water laws, and we’re living on borrowed time with our ancient, deteriorating water infrastructure. We take it for granted that when we turn on our kitchen tap, the water will be safe and healthy, but we have a long way to go before that is reality across our country.”
“Threats on Tap: Widespread Violations Highlight Need for Investment in Water Infrastructure and Protections” found nearly 80,000 violations impacting drinking water systems in every state, but under-reporting and lax enforcement could mean the number of violations is much higher. Very small systems found in rural or sparsely populated areas account for more than half of all health-based violations, and nearly 70 percent of all violations.
The report found the top dozen states with the most offenses based on population were (in order):
- New Jersey
NRDC’s report exposes health-based violations of the Safe Drinking Water Act, as well as violations for improper water monitoring and reporting, at more than 18,000 community water systems across the nation. These federal drinking water rules are intended to protect against about 100 contaminants, such as toxic chemicals, bacteria and metals like lead that can cause health impacts like cancer, birth defects, and cognitive impairments.
The report also revealed that 27 million people, or one in every 12 Americans, were served by a drinking water system with health-based violations. Health-based violations of the rules were most frequently caused by (in order): a cancer-causing family of chemicals called disinfection byproducts; coliform bacteria; the failure to properly treat surface and groundwater to remove dangerous pathogens; nitrates and nitrites that can cause “blue baby syndrome”; and lead and copper.
Meanwhile, repercussions for violations were virtually nonexistent. Nearly nine in 10 violations were subject to no formal action, and even fewer—just 3.3 percent—faced financial penalties.
Trump’s Cuts to EPA’s Budget Would Make it Worse for Rural America
President Trump’s proposed budget for the EPA would make our failing drinking water system worse. The Trump budget proposed slashing the agency’s funding by 31 percent; a leaked memo showed that water-related programs and grants at EPA totaling more than $600 million are the chopping block. NRDC’s report shows that even at its current level of funding, the EPA and states are doing an inadequate job of monitoring, testing, and enforcing safe drinking water laws. The Trump budget also proposes to eliminate all $498 million dollars in funding for rural drinking water and wastewater systems from the Department of Agriculture.
“Americans have a right to safe, clean drinking water, but President Trump is killing that right with a meat axe,” said Jamie Consuegra, a Legislative Director with NRDC. “Our tap water should not poison us or make us sick. We can’t play politics with our health or our children’s future.”
Deeper budget cuts could spell disaster, especially for rural America.
“There’s a two-tiered drinking water system in this nation and rural America is most at risk from the inequality. Small systems have the highest percentage of water violations, and it’s largely due to financial and technical capacity issues that will only get worse when the EPA cuts drinking water programs,” said Mae Wu, Senior Attorney with NRDC’s Health program.
Beyond regulated contaminants, which are the focus of this report, many more unregulated contaminants are also found in drinking water. The EPA has not set a single standard for a new drinking water contaminant since the law was amended in 1996 to change the way new contaminants are regulated. Only one chemical—perchlorate (a component of rocket fuel)—has been slated for regulation. However, since the agency made that decision six years ago, it has failed to even propose a standard. Other unregulated contaminants ripe for EPA regulation include algal toxins, the Teflon-related chemicals PFOA and PFOS, the carcinogen hexavalent chromium, and the pathogen that causes Legionnaire’s disease.
The report notes, however, that proposals being actively moved in Congress, such as the so-called Regulatory Accountability Act, would make it all but impossible for EPA to adopt new tap water protections or strengthen current ones.
Safeguarding our Tap Water
Investing and improving infrastructure and enforcing the drinking water laws are solutions that will make a difference. The NRDC recommends that the nation must:
- Improve water infrastructure and modernize drinking water treatment plants. This includes removing the 6 million to 10 million lead service lines across the country.
- Increase funding for water infrastructure to protect health and create good jobs. Congress should increase water infrastructure funding, which will also create millions of well-paid jobs fixing the nation’s water system.
- Strengthen and enforce existing regulations, and establish new ones. Many contaminants found in drinking water – including pharmaceuticals and industrial chemicals – are not regulated, leaving everyone with potentially unsafe drinking water.
- Develop a more robust testing system for drinking water contaminants.
“Threats on Tap” is a follow-up to NRDC’s 2016 study that revealed widespread lead contamination in the tap water in Flint, Michigan, and towns across America.
The full report, interactive maps, and FAQs are available online here.
A consumer’s guide to safe water can be found here.